The South African Broadcasting Corporation (SABC) is facing mounting criticism after journalist Juliet Newell was abruptly taken off air following an interview about the conflict between Israel and Palestine, particularly touching on what is currently happening in Gaza.
The controversy erupted when Newell challenged her guest, Dr Mamphela Ramphele, a respected academic, medical doctor, anti-apartheid activist and former World Bank managing director. Ramphele had drawn parallels between the humanitarian crisis in Gaza and the Holocaust. Newell questioned this comparison on historical grounds.
Her intervention was cut short, and within hours, SABC confirmed her removal, sparking outrage across South Africa and beyond. The move has reignited debates over media freedom, political pressure, and the responsibility of journalists when navigating sensitive global conflicts.
SABC SILENCES JOURNALIST AMID HOLOCAUST DEBATE
Dr Ramphele, who was a close partner of Black Consciousness leader Steve Biko and later a leading figure in South African politics, argued that Gaza’s suffering bore similarities to the Holocaust. Newell pushed back, asking whether such a comparison risked trivialising the genocide of six million Jews.
Within hours, the SABC announced her removal, sparking criticism from local and international observers, including Jewish organisations and press freedom advocates.
A PATTERN OF PRESSURE ON MEDIA VOICES?
This is not the first time the SABC has faced accusations of bowing to political and public pressure. Analysts suggest the broadcaster is caught between upholding journalistic integrity and navigating deeply polarised public opinion on the Israel–Palestine conflict.
The South African Jewish Report noted that silencing journalists over Holocaust-related discourse risks fuelling further antisemitism while undermining honest debate.
WHY THE HOLOCAUST COMPARISON MATTERS
Historians and Jewish leaders argue that equating modern conflicts with the Holocaust not only distorts history but also risks inflaming antisemitic narratives. Meanwhile, Palestinian solidarity groups insist that such comparisons underscore the severity of Gaza’s humanitarian crisis.
Caught in the middle are journalists like Newell, who are tasked with asking difficult questions, yet facing backlash for doing their jobs.
SHOULD JOURNALISTS BE SILENCED FOR ASKING TOUGH QUESTIONS?
Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 11.
Subscribe to The South African website’s newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
